For starters, the show will be exclusive to Fox for season two, after season one ran on both the broadcast network and Amazon’s Prime Video streaming platform. The show will also have a new host, with Joel McHale taking over from Patton Oswalt.

Joel McHale is replacing Patton Oswalt as the host of The 1% Club after the game show's move to Fox. "I am 1,000,000 percent excited to be partnering with Fox to host The 1% Club," McHale, 53, said in a statement on Thursday,

The 1% Club' has been renewed for a second season, moving to Fox from Amazon Prime Video and with Joel McHale replacing Patton Oswalt as host.

The 1% Club has been renewed for a second season at Fox, with Amazon taking a step back. The game show originally premiered on Prime Video in 2024, with Fox as a broadcast partner. Fox will now air the show exclusively for its 2025-26 season,

There was even talk that Patrick Dempsey, who played Mark Kincaid in Scream 3, and was later said to be married to and have a family with Sidney Prescott, might also join the cast, but then came the shocker: Dempsey isn't coming back,