Penn Badgley is opening up about the role that got away from him. In a recent interview with Buzzfeed, the You star was asked what role his fans would be surprised he auditioned for but didn’t get.

Related: Why Penn Badgley 'Fought to Be as Naked as Possible' in You's Dramatic Season 5 Final Sequence (Exclusive) When asked if he was happy with how the show ends, Badgley said “yeah” and ...

No doubt about it: Penn Badgley looks more like the handsome boy next door than a serial killer. That’s exactly why the actor was the perfect choice to play the murderous Joe Goldberg in WBTV ...